Our second submission for the month comes from Jennifer
Kirkeby. You can
find Jennifer at her blog. This is
the first page of her YA novel, PEACEFUL ACRES. My comments will be in purple and I hope you'll add yours. Don't forget to check out
what Dianne Salerni had to say at her blog, In High Spirits.
As soon as the
front doors slid open, I fully expected my nose hairs to disintegrate from the
sharp smell of pee (I think a boy would use the word piss) and Lysol.(Good sensory engagement) That’s how I remembered it from when I saw Grandma
in one of these places. God was that depressing. Sad and lonely faces in all
stages of decay, slumped over in wheelchairs or forever condemned to hospital
beds while staring off into space. And they were the lucky ones. Give me a
semi-truck coming eighty-miles-an-hour straight at me any day of the week. This, however, definitely sounds more male than female - imo.
So imagine my
surprise when I walked into the lobby. Not only did it look like an expensive
hotel, but once I stopped holding my breath, the only smell I noticed was the
faint scent of some kind of flower. Of course I still wasn’t convinced. After
all, this was my punishment, not a vacation.Community service perhaps? What did he do? I'm curious...
“David Ackerman?”
said the girl behind the desk.
“Yeah.”
“Welcome to
Peaceful Acres.”
As she walked
towards me, I was hit by unworldly beauty. I don’t mean she was just hot, she
was pure perfection. A goddess. Long brown hair and matching eyes.
Confident. Spectacular smile. I mean spectacular. I looked at her name
tag. Danielle Oleander. She offered her hand as she introduced herself, but if
it wasn’t for that name tag winking at me, I probably would have forgotten it.
She smelled like lilacs. And had that music been playing since I walked in? I'm no expert, but this doesn't quite sound like a YA guy to me. Let's hope some actual guys show up to offer their opinion.
“Does it hurt?”
she asked.
At first I thought
she was talking about my hand she was still shaking. Then I realized she was
looking closely at my right eye. What's wrong with his eye? Bruised? Do you want to tell us here or save it? Just asking...
“No. Well, a
little.” I tried for sympathy in case she wanted to take care of me. lol.
She let my hand
go. “Sounds like you were lucky. Your mom said it was quite a car accident.”
“Yeah, it was.”
Great. What else did my mom tell her? That I had totaled my sister's car on
purpose? Ah. And why would he do that? I'm even more curious.
“I’m glad you’re
okay.”
“Thanks,” I
squeaked. Again, this sounds more like a girl than a guy. Not that guys don't squeak upon occasion but I think squeaking is more common among girls.
“Follow me,
David.”
Maybe this
wouldn’t be so bad after all. Famous last words.
My first impression is that this sounds more like a girl's voice than a boy's. But. I do like the voice. I get a good sense of who this person is by the word choices and inner dialogue. I also like the the hints of what happened before to lead up to David arriving at Peaceful Acres; an accident, possible community service, and some sort of injury. These things all make me want to read on and find out what happened and more importantly, why. Why did David crash his sister's car on purpose? The other thing that makes me very curious is the title. Peaceful Acres. I get a huge sense of foreboding, which is emphasized by the last line, "Maybe this won't be so bad after all," and I have a strong suspicion that it is indeed going to be bad. The question is, how? I don't know about you guys but I want to read on and find out!
Voice is a mixture. It sounded adult at the beginning and in places more girl than boy. I certainly wouldn't notice the smell of flowers.
ReplyDeleteDescription parts are very vivid.
And yes, go with piss.
Thank you, Alex. I appreciate your feedback! I'm definitely going with piss. ;-)
DeleteI do notice the smell of lilacs... possibly because I have a forest of it under my window :)
ReplyDeleteYou're lucky, Dezmond. I'm looking at snow!
DeleteThe voice had me confused and if its YA ...the voice needs to be a little younger.
ReplyDeleteHugs and chocolate,
Shelly
Thank you for your feedback, Shelly. I appreciate it!
DeleteScent is a really strong sensation to go with for description, but I wonder if having two such potent mentions of it all in the space of a couple paragraphs is too much? Just a thought.
ReplyDeleteAnd, ooh, I hope you are enjoying Bring Up the Bodies, Marcy! Just as good as Wolf Hall.
Really good point, L.G. I will definitely think about that! Thanks!
DeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteI love it when authors appeal to many senses.
ReplyDeleteThanks for the comment, C. Lee!
DeleteThank you Marcy for your wonderful feedback! I'm so glad that you wanted to read on. I appreciate your critique so much. You gave me a lot of fantastic things to ponder as I continue.
ReplyDeleteMaybe I read too much paranormal but I thought we were going to find out this guy was dead and entering Hell, until we got to the "...your mom said..." part.
ReplyDeleteYou are very intuitive, LD. It's not Hell, and David's not dead...let's just say Peaceful Acres is definitely not what it sounds like!
DeleteI had a feeling there was more to Peaceful Acres...
DeleteI love the sensory details. It does seem to have a mix of female and male voice--though I believe when I'm reading that it's a male perspective.
ReplyDeleteThank you so much for your feedback! I appreciate it.
DeleteIntriguing. I'd like to see some of the language tightened up. "I expected my nose hairs to disintegrate from the smell of piss/pee and Lysol, the aroma that gagged me when I used to visit grandma at one of these places. So imagine my suprise..." I was going to ask that you be more specific about the details...what kind of flowers did he smell...but he's a boy, would he know? But then he did smell "lilacs." Perhaps at the first flower mention, you can focus on another detail he'd be clearer on. Also, when he describes Danielle, he uses generalities. She looks like a Goddess? What what characteristics does she have that make her look like that? No, it doesn't have to be a complete image, brown hair, blue eyes, etc. But we need something more specific so we can conjure our own image. Perhaps the way she walks, or how her clothes fit her, or the dimple in her cheek...just more specific.
ReplyDeleteThank you, Liza! Great feedback. I agree that there needs to be more specificity about Danielle.
DeleteThis post by Livia Blackburne might help you with the male POV:
ReplyDeletehttp://blog.liviablackburne.com/2012/05/operation-chest-hair-part-i-in-which-i.html
Thank you, Patchi! I will definitely check out this post.
DeleteThat is definitely an attention-getting first sentence, with the nose hairs disintegrating. :) Hmm, not sure most guys would know what lilacs smell like. I like the voice too; intriguing sample!
ReplyDeleteThanks so much for the comments, Carol!
DeleteMighty fine intro! I have to agree that most boys would have only a vague notion as to what lilacs are, much less how they smell. Flowers in general would work better.
ReplyDelete